More Perihelion:
Bob Sward's Writer's Friendship Series |
Rhyme Without Reason
Hapax (Northwestern University Press) Reviewed by Joan Houlihan
Reading A.E. Stallings is like watching a thoroughbred horse win the race in spite of a weighted saddle. Magnificent horse, exciting race—but the handicap is a constant distraction, often becoming, itself, the focus. Among her formalist peers, Stallings is a clear winner. Her intellect, substantive subject matter (often drawn from deep familiarity with and love of the classics), the rich and interesting diction of her poems and their varied phrasings, frequently cohere in this collection around genuine passion and something to say. These poems have legs.
Faded now, and dried,
When we stopped the car
The theft of bloom, the sting, I have some if it stillThe addition of the third line is especially inept—the phrase “in an empty glass” is seemingly connected to “we gathered on the hill” (“We gathered on the hill in an empty glass”). This line has additional problems of sense: why is the glass “empty” if there is a “bunch of wild thyme” in it? It seems that there is an extra word needed, and “empty,” though an empty one, is used to pad the line, evidently for meter's sake. Faded now, and dried,in which yet abide (!) It's as if Stallings goes deeper and deeper into a poetic collective unconscious as the poem progresses. The theft of bloom, the sting,Words like “abide,” phrases like “theft of bloom” and “a swiftness on the wing,” along with the torqued syntax and true end-rhyming signal that the poet has not only found and entered the closet of nineteenth-century poetry, but has emerged wearing the fashion of that day. That Stallings can do much better than a good imitation of the dead is evident in many other poems in the book, even those that are also end-rhymed, for example: “An Ancient Dog Grave, Unearthed During Construction of the Athens Metro,” “Actaeon,” “Nettles,” “Purgatory,” “Fragment,” “Amateur Iconography: Resurrection,” “Apotropaic,” and” Ultrasound” to name a few. In addition, Stallings' various and powerful openings are themselves small masterpieces: Jesus is back—he's harvesting the dead In fact, it is instructive to contrast “Thyme,” arguably the weakest in the collection, with another poem about a plant, “Asphodel” which uses triple end rhyme but is a strong and memorable poem. Instead of the ending “the theft of bloom, the sting,/A swiftness on the wing,/Things that sweetness cannot be without” we have: I noticed a strange fragrance. It was sweet, Like honey—but with a hint of rotting meat. An army of them bristled at my feet.Here the rhymes are redeemed by a direct and powerful diction, one that could be spoken today, and also by their amplification of the meaning of the poem. They are not empty rhymes. There are many poems in Hapax that exude energy, verve, wit and invention, and there is an obvious integrity, a wholeness throughout. Stallings' delight in order, sophistication of sensibility and deft use of the familiar, the way she balances between surprise and fulfilled expectation, gives the reader a reason to read on. It also signals the presence of a poet who has the potential to become great in her maturity. For now though, and despite all the poems in Hapax that rise above their construction around end rhyme, there remains a sense of a self-imposed handicap, a sense that the poet has not yet shed the need to construct her own straightjackets simply to demonstrate, Houdini-like, how she can escape them—if she can.
Joan Houlihan is editor-in-chief of Perihelion and the author of two books: Hand-Held Executions and The Mending Worm, winner of the 2005 Green Rose Prize from New Issues Press. She is founder and director of the Concord Poetry Center in Concord, Massachusetts. ____ Back to Perihelion |